Protecting Your Church Offering: A Guide to Internal Controls for Indianapolis Churches

It is a familiar scene in many churches. A dedicated volunteer, perhaps someone who has served faithfully for decades, quietly handles the week's offering. She, or he, gathers the plates, disappears into an office, and some time later emerges with a bank deposit bag. That same person may also be the one who enters the donations into the church’s accounting software and prepares reports for the board.

This is the way it has always been done. This volunteer is trusted completely. They are the backbone of the ministry's operations.

And yet, a new pastor or a diligent board member may feel a persistent, quiet anxiety. It is not a feeling of suspicion. It is a feeling of risk. What if there was a simple, honest mistake? What if $1,000 in cash was accidentally counted as $100? What if a check was misplaced? Without a second set of eyes, the error might never be found. The volunteer would be devastated if they knew, and the church would be out the funds.

Worse, what if the unthinkable happened? In a system where one person controls everything, the church is vulnerable. More importantly, that trusted volunteer is vulnerable to accusation.

This is the central challenge for many congregations. How do you implement financial checks and balances without offending the very people who have given so much of their time?

The solution is to reframe the entire conversation. Implementing internal controls is not an act of distrust. It is a critical act of stewardship and protection. Good policies protect the church, protect its reputation, and, most importantly, protect the volunteers themselves.

Protection, Not Suspicion: Reframing the Need for Controls

Before outlining any specific procedures, the church leadership must first establish why these changes are necessary. The conversation should never begin with a focus on fraud. It should begin with a focus on care.

1. Protecting Your Volunteers This is the most important argument. Imagine a $500 discrepancy between the offering total and the bank deposit. In a one-person system, there is only one person to ask. Even if it was a simple bank error or a miscount, that volunteer is placed in a terrible, isolated position.

A two-person system immediately diffuses this. If two people count the money together and sign off on a total, they share the responsibility. If a third person verifies the deposit, the chain of custody is clear. This system protects your volunteers from unfair suspicion or blame.

2. The Reality of Human Error People make mistakes. Even the most meticulous person can transpose numbers, add a column incorrectly, or bundle cash in the wrong denomination. These are not moral failures. They are simple facts of human life. A good system is designed to catch these honest errors early, before they become confusing problems in the financial statements.

3. Enhancing Donor Confidence Your congregation gives generously and expects the church to manage those gifts wisely. Transparency in financial handling is a cornerstone of that trust. When donors know that a professional, accountable system is in place, their confidence in the ministry's leadership and stewardship grows. They can be assured their contributions are being handled with integrity.

4. Acknowledging the Need for Deterrence While it is uncomfortable to discuss, financial fraud does happen in churches. The Association of Certified Fraud Examiners has noted that organizations with weak internal controls are significantly more vulnerable. A strong system of controls acts as a deterrent. It removes the very temptation that can arise in a situation of secrecy and sole control. This is not about suspecting your current volunteers. It is about building a healthy system that is not dependent on one person's character and will last for generations.

The Anatomy of a Secure Offering: A Step-by-Step Process

A strong set of internal controls for a church offering is built on one core principle: segregation of duties.

This principle is simple. The person who counts the money should not be the same person who records the money in the books. And neither of them should be the person who reconciles the bank statement at the end of the month.

Breaking up these key tasks ensures that no single individual has control over the entire financial process. Here is a practical, step-by-step model.

Part 1: Collection and Counting

1. The Two-Person Rule: From the moment the offering plates are collected, two unrelated people should be present. The offering should be placed in a secure, sealed bag. It should never be left unattended or taken to a volunteer's home.
2. The Counting Team: The offering must be counted by at least two unrelated individuals. This is the "count team." In a small church, this might be the head usher and a finance committee member. In a larger church, this task can be rotated among a trained team of volunteers.
3. The Secure Location: The team should count the money in a private, secure room, ideally one without excessive foot traffic.
4. The Count Sheet: This is the most critical document in the process. The count team should fill out a pre-printed form that details the following:
   • Date of the offering
   • Cash received (broken down by denomination)
   • Total of checks received (a list of each check is ideal)
   • Total offering (Cash + Checks)
   • The signatures of both counters.
5. Handling the Funds: As checks are counted, they should immediately be stamped with a "For Deposit Only" endorser for the church's bank account. Cash should be bundled neatly.

Once the count is complete, the total on the count sheet should be finalized. Both counters sign it. This form is now the church's official record of what was received.

Part 2: Deposit and Recording

6. Preparing the Deposit: The count team should prepare the bank deposit slip. The total on the deposit slip must match the total on the signed count sheet. The cash, checks, count sheet, and deposit slip are then placed in a locking bank bag.
7. Making the Deposit: Ideally, a different person (or two people) from the count team takes the deposit to the bank. This could be a staff member or another trusted volunteer. This person should get a stamped, itemized receipt from the bank teller. This receipt is crucial. The deposit should be made as soon as possible, ideally the same day or the next business day.
8. The Bookkeeping Entry: Now, a third person enters the picture. This is the church bookkeeper, administrator, or treasurer. This person should not have been part of the counting or deposit process. They receive two documents:
   • The Signed Count Sheet (from the count team)
   • The Stamped Bank Receipt (from the depositor)
   The bookkeeper’s first job is to verify that the total on the count sheet matches the total on the bank receipt. If they match, the bookkeeper makes the entry into the accounting system based on the count sheet data. If they do not match, the discrepancy must be investigated and resolved immediately.

Part 3: Oversight and Reconciliation

9. The Final Check: The loop is closed by a fourth person (or entity). This individual should have no role in counting, depositing, or day-to-day bookkeeping. This is often the pastor, a non-finance board member, or an external bookkeeping service.
10. This person should receive the monthly bank statement directly from the bank (or have read-only online access). They then perform the bank reconciliation, or carefully review the reconciliation prepared by the bookkeeper. Their job is to verify that the deposits recorded in the accounting system match what actually appeared on the bank statement. This independent review ensures the entire process is working and that all funds are accounted for.

How to Introduce Change Without Causing Hurt

This system sounds robust, but how do you implement it without hurting the feelings of the long-time volunteer who has always "just handled it"?

This is a matter of leadership and pastoral care.

• Start with Honor. Begin by publicly and privately honoring the volunteer for their years of faithful service. Acknowledge that the church's current health is, in part, due to their dedication.
• Frame it as Protection. Use the language of protection. "Mary, you have done so much for this church, and we have failed to protect you. We have put you in a vulnerable position where any mistake or question would fall entirely on you. We are going to fix that by building a team around you."
• Cite "Best Practices." Explain this as a "best practice" recommended by insurance companies, auditors, and denominations. This moves the decision from a personal one to a professional one. It is not about her. It is about the church growing in maturity and financial integrity.
• Elevate, Don't Discard. Ask that dedicated volunteer to help you build the new system. Make them the "team leader" who trains and oversees the new counters. Their experience is invaluable. This changes their role from doer to supervisor, which is often a respectful way to transition responsibility.

A Note on Modern Giving

These controls are primarily for cash and checks. Online giving platforms, thankfully, have many of these controls built in. Donations are processed by a third party, and deposits are made directly to the church's account. This creates a clear digital trail.

However, the core principle of segregation of duties still applies. The person who administers the online giving platform (pulling reports, etc.) should not be the same person who reconciles the bank account.

A Foundation for Ministry

Creating these safeguards is a profound act of care. It is not about adding bureaucracy. It is about building a foundation of accountability that frees the church to focus on its mission. It honors the generosity of your congregation. It protects the integrity of the volunteers who serve so faithfully.

A secure financial process is the bedrock of a healthy, growing church. If you are unsure where to begin, a consultation with a professional bookkeeping service can provide a clear, respectful path forward.

‍